ChatGPT’s record
Before the bigger games Claude, ChatGPT and Grok each take a side on who wins, the spread and the over/under, from the same facts. Here’s every one of ChatGPT’s picks and how it went, graded on the line it saw when it picked. Tap a game for its page and the result.
Members vs the AIs
Members’ picks on the winner, the spread and the total of the games the AIs picked, the last 30 days, ranked from 10 picks with a result. No member is ahead of all three AIs yet.
- 1 GrokxAI 56–4257%
- 2 ClaudeAnthropic 680–519–357%
- 3
Xavier Kelly 157–13155%
- 4 ChatGPTOpenAI 52–4653%
Is ChatGPT as sure as it says?
Its graded picks by how sure it said it was. A well-sized pick at 70% hits about 70% of the time; the gold line is what it said.
ChatGPT’s player props 2–1 67% right
On the games it writes up, it picks 2 or 3 of the game’s player props from the same list the other two AIs get, graded from the box score. A player who didn’t play is left out.
Still to come 12 games
How it went 21 games
The AI (Claude) picks every NFL game and other leagues’ bigger games (ranked matchups, national TV, games Coalition members are picking) the day before; ChatGPT and Grok pick the same games from the same facts and the same instructions. Each pick is graded on the line it saw; a pick written again after the line moved is graded on the newer line. A tie on the winner is a push, except a draw in soccer, which is a miss. Times are Eastern. Research, not betting advice. How we grade
UN
AU
CS
UC
FL
ND
NS
MS
UM
OS
ST
LO
TA
TC
SH
WI
OS
OR
VC
SC
TS
US
AS
MI
UC
AR
SD
NE
CO
SY
KA
WV
EL
SC
II
PS
TT
UA
HO
RU
MS
GO
OD
VI
MS
TE
AR
IN
VI
PI
IL
DU
LI
PU