Records you can trust
How we grade picks
Every record on The Coalition follows the same rules. Picks close at kickoff, the app grades them from the final score, and losses stay on the record.
- Closed at kickoffNo new picks or slips on a game that has started.
- Graded from the scoreFinal scores and box scores, by the app, not by hand.
- Losses stayAfter kickoff a slip can’t be pulled or deleted.
- Each pick counts onceThe same pick on two slips is one pick.
When a pick counts
- Before the game starts. Once a game starts, the app won’t take a new pick or slip on it, and a placed slip on it can’t be deleted.
- A posted slip can be pulled until its first game starts. A pulled slip says so on its page and doesn’t count for or against anyone. After kickoff it stays, win or lose.
- At the number you took. Each pick keeps the line and odds it was made at. If the line moves later, the record still uses yours.
How it’s graded
- From the final score. The app reads each game’s final score (and the box score for player props) and grades every pick on it soon after the final.
- Overs can win early. An over on a game total or a team total is marked won as soon as the live score passes the line, since points only go up.
- Exactly on the number is a push. A spread that lands on the line and a total that lands on the number both push.
- Ties. A tie pushes a two-way moneyline. In soccer, a draw loses a pick on either team to win.
- Player props. A player who never gets into the game makes the prop void.
- Canceled and postponed games. A canceled game voids every pick on it. A postponed game waits until it’s played.
- Tennis. A walkover voids the match. If a player retires, only what was already decided stands.
- Slips. A slip loses as soon as one leg loses. A pushed or voided leg drops out and the slip pays on the legs that won. If every leg pushes, the stake comes back.
What goes on a record
4-leg slip
Chiefs −3.5Over 47.5Lakers MLUnder 6.5
Slip lost
Adds to the record3–13 wins, 1 loss
- A record counts picks, not slips. Each leg is a pick, so the parlay above adds three wins and a loss even though the slip lost. Each slip’s own result shows on the slip.
- Each pick counts once. The same side in two pools, on two slips, or in a pool and your own bets is one pick.
- Hit rate is wins divided by wins plus losses. Pushes and voided picks don’t count. 10 picks with a result get someone a rank on Tail > Callers.
- Best return is what $10 on every pick would have made at each pick’s odds. Picks with no odds are left out of the money.
- Most money made counts slips, not picks: what the slips someone posted on Tail paid back minus what they bet, at the stakes they posted. It’s the same money as on their page. Open and pulled slips don’t count.
- Beats the close is how often a pick’s number was better than the last line before the game. It shows after 10 picks with a closing line.
- This week covers the last 7 days. Hot streak is straight wins still going (a push doesn’t break it), Best week is $10 a pick, and Best in a league needs 5 picks with a result. Every row also shows the overall record.
- A member’s picks are the ones they add in their pools, their own bets and the slips they tail. A private profile shows only to pool mates.
Callers we track on X
- Read from their public posts. We turn the picks in a caller’s posts on X into slips here and grade them like anyone else’s. They don’t run their pages here.
- Posted before kickoff, or not at all. A pick counts only if the post went up before its game started, even when we read it later.
- Unclear posts get a second read. An AI check decides whether a hard-to-read post is a pick. Anything still unclear is left out, and anyone can flag a read with Read wrong?
- Units. A caller’s units turn into dollars at one amount per unit, shown at the top of their page.
- No odds in the post. The pick takes the books’ price from when it was posted (the first price after it, if the books didn’t have one yet), so the slip shows what it pays. Until the books have one, it says the odds are unknown.
The AI’s picks
- Every take is graded. Before a game the AI picks a winner, a side against the spread and the total, and each one is graded against the line it saw.
- Hits and misses. Every game it picked is on the AI’s record.
If something looks wrong
A wrong score, a pick graded the wrong way or a read from X that missed: ask for help. A site admin fixes the result and the record updates everywhere it shows.