The Coalition
Group bets Tail Research Find a pool Sign in Sign up
CFB · Every game Claude picked

Claude’s record

Before the bigger games Claude, ChatGPT and Grok each take a side on who wins, the spread and the over/under, from the same facts. Here’s every one of Claude’s picks and how it went, graded on the line it saw when it picked. Tap a game for its page and the result.

ClaudeAnthropic 107–40 73%67–76–2 47%78–69 53%7–4 64% ChatGPTOpenAI 3–1 75%0–4 0%0–4 0%6–3 67% GrokxAI 3–1 75%2–2 50%1–3 25%7–4 64%

Members vs the AIs

Members’ picks on the winner, the spread and the total of the games the AIs picked, the last 30 days, ranked from 10 picks with a result. No member is ahead of all three AIs yet.

  1. 1 GrokxAI 52–3560%
  2. 2 ClaudeAnthropic 674–514–357%
  3. 3 ChatGPTOpenAI 48–3955%
  4. 4 Xavier Kelly 155–13054%
Picking winners
107–40
73% right · 147 picks
Against the spread
67–76–2
47% right · 145 picks, 2 pushes left out
Over / under
78–69
53% right · 147 picks

Is Claude as sure as it says?

Its graded picks by how sure it said it was. A well-sized pick at 70% hits about 70% of the time; the gold line is what it said.

Said 50–59% 49% hit · 146–149
Said 60–69% 63% hit · 53–31
Said 70–80% 91% hit · 53–5

Claude’s player props 7–4 64% right

On the games it writes up, it picks 2 or 3 of the game’s player props from the same list the other two AIs get, graded from the box score. A player who didn’t play is left out.

AKR at MASS Nov 18 Jordan Gant Over 11.5 rec yds 60%Hit · 15Miles Burris Over 31.5 rec yds 58%Hit · 59Cibastian Broughton Under 203.5 pass yds 62%Hit · 165
M-OH at KENT Nov 17 Dru DeShields Under 215.5 pass yds 55%Hit · 92Wayne Harris Under 67.5 rec yds 54%Hit · 46Brendyn Smith Over 23.5 rec yds 58%Miss
BALL at OHIO Nov 17 Riley Neer Over 58.5 rec yds 58%Hit · 92Keldric Luster Under 188.5 pass yds 55%Miss · 257Donovan Hamilton Over 51.5 rec yds 54%Miss · 39
EMU at WMU Nov 17 Aveion Chenault Over 51.5 rec yds 62%Didn’t playAmareon Blue Over 37.5 rush yds 61%Hit · 160Harold Mack Over 3.5 receptions 58%Miss · 1

How it went 147 games · page 2 of 3

Sat, Nov 7 25 games
FinalUCFUCF33at KansasKansas32WinnerKU61%MissSpreadUCF +356%HitTotalUnder 47.555%Miss1 of 3
FinalMarshallMarshall13at Georgia SouthernGeorgia Southern49WinnerGASO75%HitSpreadGASO −10.558%HitTotalUnder 54.555%Miss2 of 3
FinalTempleTemple35at NavyNavy42WinnerNAVY68%HitSpreadNAVY −7.561%MissTotalUnder 54.554%Miss1 of 3
FinalCharlotteCharlotte12at UABUAB23WinnerUAB70%HitSpreadUAB −8.558%HitTotalOver 47.555%Miss2 of 3
FinalMerrimackMerrimack0at Wake ForestWake Forest77WinnerWAKE78%HitSpreadWAKE −47.558%HitTotalUnder 58.555%Miss2 of 3
FinalAlabamaAlabama31at LSULSU13WinnerLSU60%MissSpreadALA +655%HitTotalOver 52.558%Miss1 of 3
FinalOregonOregon41at Ohio StateOhio State28WinnerOSU70%MissSpreadOSU −7.558%MissTotalUnder 46.556%Miss0 of 3
FinalPenn StatePenn State28at WashingtonWashington25WinnerWASH56%MissSpreadWASH −2.552%MissTotalUnder 44.554%Miss0 of 3
FinalCincinnatiCincinnati24at HoustonHouston31WinnerHOU68%HitSpreadHOU −10.556%MissTotalOver 62.555%Miss1 of 3
FinalDelawareDelaware40at Kennesaw StateKennesaw State42WinnerDEL60%MissSpreadDEL −1.555%MissTotalUnder 57.555%Miss0 of 3
FinalUL MonroeUL Monroe19at Arkansas StateArkansas State17WinnerARST65%MissSpreadARST −14.555%MissTotalOver 53.555%Miss0 of 3
FinalTexas A&MTexas A&M9at South CarolinaSouth Carolina17WinnerSC60%HitSpreadTA&M +755%MissTotalUnder 50.555%Hit2 of 3
FinalGeorgia StateGeorgia State39at App StateApp State23WinnerAPP60%MissSpreadAPP −652%MissTotalUnder 54.555%Miss0 of 3
FinalOklahoma StateOklahoma State66at Kansas StateKansas State28WinnerOKST62%HitSpreadKSU +6.554%MissTotalOver 62.555%Hit2 of 3
FinalArkansasArkansas23at AuburnAuburn26WinnerAUB72%HitSpreadAUB −1058%MissTotalUnder 53.555%Hit2 of 3
FinalMarylandMaryland34at PurduePurdue29WinnerPUR70%MissSpreadPUR −5.555%MissTotalUnder 56.555%Miss0 of 3
FinalDukeDuke41at NC StateNC State3WinnerDUKE62%HitSpreadDUKE −455%HitTotalOver 51.552%Miss2 of 3
FinalTulsaTulsa60at TulaneTulane10WinnerTLSA56%HitSpreadTULN +2.552%MissTotalOver 49.553%Hit2 of 3
FinalNorth CarolinaNorth Carolina38at UConnUConn21WinnerUNC65%HitSpreadCONN +755%MissTotalOver 54.560%Hit2 of 3
FinalFlorida StateFlorida State31at Boston CollegeBoston College24WinnerFSU62%HitSpreadFSU −6.555%HitTotalUnder 52.554%Miss2 of 3
FinalClemsonClemson18at SyracuseSyracuse13WinnerCLEM58%HitSpreadSYR +2.555%MissTotalOver 49.554%Miss1 of 3
FinalTexasTexas34at MissouriMissouri20WinnerTEX62%HitSpreadMIZ +2.554%MissTotalUnder 42.555%Miss1 of 3
FinalBYUBYU20at UtahUtah28WinnerUTAH62%HitSpreadUTAH −4.554%HitTotalUnder 48.555%Hit3 of 3
FinalIowa StateIowa State31at BaylorBaylor42WinnerBAY70%HitSpreadBAY −1055%HitTotalUnder 51.552%Miss2 of 3
FinalUCLAUCLA34at MinnesotaMinnesota20WinnerUCLA66%HitSpreadUCLA −5.557%HitTotalUnder 38.555%Miss2 of 3
Fri, Nov 6 5 games
FinalTCUTCU28at ArizonaArizona29WinnerARIZ70%HitSpreadARIZ −7.556%MissTotalUnder 46.552%Miss1 of 3
FinalNew MexicoNew Mexico31at NevadaNevada3WinnerUNM70%HitSpreadUNM −1058%HitTotalUnder 38.556%Hit3 of 3
FinalNebraskaNebraska13at IllinoisIllinois24WinnerNEB60%MissSpreadNEB −4.555%MissTotalUnder 50.555%Hit1 of 3
FinalSouth FloridaSouth Florida17at East CarolinaEast Carolina20WinnerECU54%HitSpreadUSF +2.552%MissTotalUnder 39.555%Hit2 of 3
FinalVirginia TechVirginia Tech28at SMUSMU51WinnerSMU63%HitSpreadSMU −6.554%HitTotalUnder 56.552%Miss2 of 3
Thu, Nov 5 2 games
FinalJames MadisonJames Madison54at Southern MissSouthern Miss23WinnerJMU65%HitSpreadJMU −13.558%HitTotalOver 58.555%Hit3 of 3
FinalUTSAUTSA29at Florida AtlanticFlorida Atlantic60WinnerUTSA65%MissSpreadUTSA −755%MissTotalOver 72.558%Hit1 of 3
Wed, Nov 4 3 games
FinalCentral MichiganCentral Michigan35vs Eastern MichiganEastern Michigan7WinnerEMU54%MissSpreadEMU +2.554%MissTotalUnder 44.554%Hit1 of 3
FinalToledoToledo20at Sacramento StateSacramento State17WinnerTOL80%HitSpreadTOL −25.560%MissTotalOver 52.555%Miss1 of 3
FinalBall StateBall State30at MassachusettsMassachusetts31WinnerMASS62%HitSpreadMASS −2.556%MissTotalUnder 48.554%Miss1 of 3
Tue, Nov 3 2 games
FinalBuffaloBuffalo34at Miami (OH)Miami (OH)31WinnerM-OH63%MissSpreadBUFF +6.555%HitTotalUnder 45.556%Miss1 of 3
FinalOhioOhio28at AkronAkron20WinnerOHIO70%HitSpreadOHIO −12.565%MissTotalUnder 51.558%Hit2 of 3
Sat, Oct 31 23 games
FinalOregon StateOregon State22at Fresno StateFresno State38WinnerORST62%MissSpreadORST −655%MissTotalOver 57.554%Hit1 of 3
FinalNorthern IllinoisNorthern Illinois24at UNLVUNLV31WinnerUNLV78%HitSpreadUNLV −21.558%MissTotalUnder 55.555%Hit2 of 3
FinalArmyArmy22at MemphisMemphis49WinnerMEM62%HitSpreadMEM −654%HitTotalOver 60.552%Hit3 of 3
FinalWashingtonWashington17at NebraskaNebraska10WinnerNEB65%MissSpreadNEB −7.555%MissTotalUnder 49.555%Hit1 of 3
FinalMissouriMissouri34at ArkansasArkansas10WinnerMIZ68%HitSpreadMIZ −1057%HitTotalUnder 48.554%Hit3 of 3
FinalGeorgia TechGeorgia Tech11at PittsburghPittsburgh34WinnerPITT68%HitSpreadPITT −7.556%HitTotalOver 54.555%Miss2 of 3
FinalMississippi StateMississippi State3at TexasTexas31WinnerTEX75%HitSpreadMSST +20.557%MissTotalOver 50.555%Miss1 of 3
FinalOhio StateOhio State18at USCUSC30WinnerOSU68%MissSpreadOSU −6.557%MissTotalUnder 50.554%Hit1 of 3
FinalMiamiMiami38at North CarolinaNorth Carolina35WinnerMIA75%HitSpreadMIA −1460%MissTotalOver 53.555%Hit2 of 3
FinalWashington StateWashington State20at San Diego StateSan Diego State26WinnerSDSU57%HitSpreadSDSU −2.554%HitTotalUnder 47.552%Hit3 of 3
FinalClemsonClemson36at Florida StateFlorida State24WinnerFSU60%MissSpreadFSU −654%MissTotalUnder 50.555%Miss0 of 3
FinalOklahoma StateOklahoma State49at Iowa StateIowa State51WinnerOKST68%MissSpreadOKST −9.555%MissTotalOver 58.556%Hit1 of 3
FinalApp StateApp State3at Georgia SouthernGeorgia Southern19WinnerGASO60%HitSpreadAPP +655%MissTotalUnder 55.555%Hit2 of 3
FinalSouth CarolinaSouth Carolina42at OklahomaOklahoma25WinnerOU62%MissSpreadSC +3.555%HitTotalOver 44.555%Hit2 of 3
FinalNevadaNevada0at UCLAUCLA27WinnerUCLA75%HitSpreadUCLA −22.558%HitTotalUnder 42.555%Hit3 of 3
FinalPurduePurdue17at Penn StatePenn State31WinnerPSU68%HitSpreadPSU −1056%HitTotalOver 55.552%Miss2 of 3
FinalNew MexicoNew Mexico21at San José StateSan José State16WinnerUNM70%HitSpreadUNM −14.555%MissTotalOver 42.555%Miss1 of 3
FinalVirginiaVirginia7at Wake ForestWake Forest51WinnerWAKE75%HitSpreadWAKE −12.558%HitTotalUnder 47.558%Miss2 of 3
FinalUtahUtah49at CincinnatiCincinnati25WinnerUTAH66%HitSpreadUTAH −757%HitTotalUnder 56.554%Miss2 of 3
FinalFlorida InternationalFlorida International10at LibertyLiberty49WinnerLIB75%HitSpreadLIB −1455%HitTotalUnder 45.555%Miss2 of 3
FinalUTEPUTEP7at North Dakota StateNorth Dakota State31WinnerNDSU70%HitSpreadNDSU −24.558%MissTotalUnder 43.555%Hit2 of 3
FinalColorado StateColorado State14at Utah StateUtah State31WinnerUSU66%HitSpreadCSU +8.556%MissTotalUnder 60.558%Hit2 of 3
FinalKansasKansas16at TCUTCU22WinnerTCU62%HitSpreadTCU −6.554%MissTotalUnder 45.555%Hit2 of 3

The AI (Claude) picks every NFL game and other leagues’ bigger games (ranked matchups, national TV, games Coalition members are picking) the day before; ChatGPT and Grok pick the same games from the same facts and the same instructions. Each pick is graded on the line it saw; a pick written again after the line moved is graded on the newer line. A tie on the winner is a push, except a draw in soccer, which is a miss. Times are Eastern. Research, not betting advice. How we grade

Plan your picks with your groupPick together, split the slips, track every dollar. Free.