Before the bigger games Claude, ChatGPT and Grok each take a side on who wins, the spread and the over/under, from the same facts. Here’s every one of Claude’s picks and how it went, graded on the line it saw when it picked. Tap a game for its page and the result.
Members’ picks on the winner, the spread and the total of the games the AIs picked, the last 30 days, ranked from 10 picks with a result.
No member is ahead of all three AIs yet.
Its graded picks by how sure it said it was. A well-sized pick at 70% hits about 70% of the time; the gold line is what it said.
Said 50–59%58% hit · 38–27
Said 60–69%77% hit · 10–3
Said 70–80%No picks yet
Claude’s player props 4–2 67% right
On the games it writes up, it picks 2 or 3 of the game’s player props from the same list the other two AIs get, graded from the box score. A player who didn’t play is left out.
DAL at VGK Nov 17Jason Robertson Over 2.5 SOG 65%Hit · 3Mitch Marner Over 0.5 points 68%Miss · 0Mikko Rantanen Over 0.5 points 60%Hit · 4
TOR at CHI Nov 17Connor Bedard Over 0.5 points 66%Hit · 1Jack Roslovic Over 0.5 points 60%Hit · 1William Nylander Over 2.5 SOG 54%Miss · 2
Still to come 2 games
TimeGameWinnerSpreadTotalRight
LiveWed, Nov 18BBBoston BruinsBruins2DRatDetroit Red WingsRed Wings1WinnerBOS50%LiveSpreadDET −1.550%LiveTotalUnder 6.550%Live
10:00 PMWed, Nov 18CAColorado AvalancheAvalancheUMatUtah MammothMammothWinnerCOL52%To comeSpreadUTA −1.552%To comeTotalOver 6.552%To come
How it went 27 games
TimeGameWinnerSpreadTotalRight
Yesterday Tue, Nov 17 2 games
FinalDSDallas StarsStars4VGatVegas Golden KnightsGolden Knights3WinnerVGK58%MissSpreadVGK −1.552%MissTotalOver 5.555%Hit1 of 3
FinalTMToronto Maple LeafsMaple Leafs3CBatChicago BlackhawksBlackhawks6WinnerCHI55%HitSpreadCHI +1.550%HitTotalOver 6.555%Hit3 of 3
Mon, Nov 16 1 game
FinalMCMontreal CanadiensCanadiens1NYatNew York RangersRangers3WinnerMTL55%MissSpreadNYR +1.556%HitTotalUnder 6.555%Hit2 of 3
Sat, Nov 14 1 game
FinalSKSeattle KrakenKraken1CHvsCarolina HurricanesHurricanes5WinnerCAR65%HitSpreadCAR −1.555%HitTotalUnder 6.555%Hit3 of 3
Thu, Nov 12 4 games
FinalDRDetroit Red WingsRed Wings4FPatFlorida PanthersPanthers5WinnerFLA62%HitSpreadDET +1.555%HitTotalOver 5.554%Hit3 of 3
FinalCAColorado AvalancheAvalanche3OSatOttawa SenatorsSenators4WinnerCOL55%MissSpreadCOL −1.552%MissTotalUnder 6.552%Miss0 of 3
FinalMWMinnesota WildWild5TMatToronto Maple LeafsMaple Leafs2WinnerMIN60%HitSpreadMIN −1.555%HitTotalUnder 6.555%Miss2 of 3
FinalCHCarolina HurricanesHurricanes4SKvsSeattle KrakenKraken1WinnerCAR62%HitSpreadCAR −1.553%HitTotalOver 6.555%Miss2 of 3
Wed, Nov 11 3 games
FinalNPNashville PredatorsPredators4ADatAnaheim DucksDucks2WinnerANA56%MissSpreadNSH +1.552%HitTotalOver 6.554%Miss1 of 3
FinalUMUtah MammothMammoth3VGatVegas Golden KnightsGolden Knights5WinnerVGK62%HitSpreadVGK −1.555%HitTotalUnder 6.554%Miss2 of 3
FinalTBTampa Bay LightningLightning8BSatBuffalo SabresSabres3WinnerTB62%HitSpreadTB −1.552%HitTotalOver 6.555%Hit3 of 3
Tue, Nov 10 7 games
FinalNPNashville PredatorsPredators3LAatLos Angeles KingsKings0WinnerNSH57%HitSpreadNSH +1.555%HitTotalUnder 6.552%Hit3 of 3
FinalDRDetroit Red WingsRed Wings2SLatSt. Louis BluesBlues3WinnerSTL58%HitSpreadSTL −1.554%MissTotalUnder 5.552%Hit2 of 3
FinalFPFlorida PanthersPanthers4CBatColumbus Blue JacketsBlue Jackets1WinnerFLA55%HitSpreadCBJ +1.555%MissTotalUnder 5.555%Hit2 of 3
FinalNJNew Jersey DevilsDevils2WJatWinnipeg JetsJets4WinnerNJ62%MissSpreadWPG +1.556%HitTotalUnder 6.555%Hit2 of 3
FinalWCWashington CapitalsCapitals3OSatOttawa SenatorsSenators2WinnerOTT55%MissSpreadOTT +1.554%HitTotalOver 6.552%Miss1 of 3
FinalMWMinnesota WildWild2MCatMontreal CanadiensCanadiens1WinnerMIN55%HitSpreadMTL +1.556%HitTotalUnder 6.554%Hit3 of 3
FinalCAColorado AvalancheAvalanche6TMatToronto Maple LeafsMaple Leafs3WinnerCOL58%HitSpreadTOR +1.554%MissTotalOver 6.556%Hit2 of 3
Mon, Nov 9 3 games
FinalNYNew York IslandersIslanders2SJatSan Jose SharksSharks3WinnerNYI57%MissSpreadSJ +1.554%HitTotalUnder 6.555%Hit2 of 3
FinalPFPhiladelphia FlyersFlyers3VCatVancouver CanucksCanucks1WinnerPHI58%HitSpreadVAN +1.556%MissTotalOver 6.555%Miss1 of 3
FinalNYNew York RangersRangers1EOatEdmonton OilersOilers3WinnerEDM62%HitSpreadNYR +1.556%MissTotalOver 6.555%Miss1 of 3
Wed, Nov 4 2 games
FinalSJSan Jose SharksSharks2LAatLos Angeles KingsKings7WinnerSJ54%MissSpreadSJ +1.555%MissTotalUnder 6.552%Miss0 of 3
FinalCBChicago BlackhawksBlackhawks3FPatFlorida PanthersPanthers5WinnerFLA65%HitSpreadFLA −1.554%HitTotalUnder 5.555%Miss2 of 3
Tue, Nov 3 1 game
FinalEOEdmonton OilersOilers3NJatNew Jersey DevilsDevils4WinnerNJ56%HitSpreadEDM +1.552%HitTotalOver 6.554%Hit3 of 3
Wed, Oct 28 1 game
FinalPFPhiladelphia FlyersFlyers2WCatWashington CapitalsCapitals5WinnerWSH60%HitSpreadWSH55%No lineTotalUnder 5.555%Miss1 of 2
Tue, Oct 27 2 games
FinalBSBuffalo SabresSabres2SJatSan Jose SharksSharks0WinnerSJ69%MissSpreadSJ69%No lineTotalOver 6.569%Miss0 of 2
FinalBBBoston BruinsBruins1CHatCarolina HurricanesHurricanes2WinnerCAR62%HitSpreadBOS55%No lineTotalOver 6.556%Miss1 of 2
The AI (Claude) picks every NFL game and other leagues’ bigger games (ranked matchups, national TV, games Coalition members are picking) the day before; ChatGPT and Grok pick the same games from the same facts and the same instructions. Each pick is graded on the line it saw; a pick written again after the line moved is graded on the newer line. A tie on the winner is a push, except a draw in soccer, which is a miss. Times are Eastern. Research, not betting advice. How we grade
Plan your picks with your groupPick together, split the slips, track every dollar. Free.