The Coalition
Group bets Tail Research Find a pool Sign in Sign up
NHL · Every game Claude picked

Claude’s record

Before the bigger games Claude, ChatGPT and Grok each take a side on who wins, the spread and the over/under, from the same facts. Here’s every one of Claude’s picks and how it went, graded on the line it saw when it picked. Tap a game for its page and the result.

ClaudeAnthropic 18–9 67%16–8 67%14–13 52%4–2 67% ChatGPTOpenAI 0–2 0%2–0 100%1–1 50%3–1 75% GrokxAI 0–2 0%2–0 100%0–2 0%4–2 67%

Members vs the AIs

Members’ picks on the winner, the spread and the total of the games the AIs picked, the last 30 days, ranked from 10 picks with a result. No member is ahead of all three AIs yet.

  1. 1 GrokxAI 43–2960%
  2. 2 ChatGPTOpenAI 42–3058%
  3. 3 ClaudeAnthropic 669–504–357%
  4. 4 Xavier Kelly 154–12855%
Picking winners
18–9
67% right · 27 picks
Against the spread
16–8
67% right · 24 picks
Over / under
14–13
52% right · 27 picks

Is Claude as sure as it says?

Its graded picks by how sure it said it was. A well-sized pick at 70% hits about 70% of the time; the gold line is what it said.

Said 50–59% 58% hit · 38–27
Said 60–69% 77% hit · 10–3
Said 70–80% No picks yet

Claude’s player props 4–2 67% right

On the games it writes up, it picks 2 or 3 of the game’s player props from the same list the other two AIs get, graded from the box score. A player who didn’t play is left out.

DAL at VGK Nov 17 Jason Robertson Over 2.5 SOG 65%Hit · 3Mitch Marner Over 0.5 points 68%Miss · 0Mikko Rantanen Over 0.5 points 60%Hit · 4
TOR at CHI Nov 17 Connor Bedard Over 0.5 points 66%Hit · 1Jack Roslovic Over 0.5 points 60%Hit · 1William Nylander Over 2.5 SOG 54%Miss · 2

Still to come 2 games

LiveWed, Nov 18Boston BruinsBruins2at Detroit Red WingsRed Wings1WinnerBOS50%LiveSpreadDET −1.550%LiveTotalUnder 6.550%Live
10:00 PMWed, Nov 18Colorado AvalancheAvalancheat Utah MammothMammothWinnerCOL52%To comeSpreadUTA −1.552%To comeTotalOver 6.552%To come

How it went 27 games

Yesterday Tue, Nov 17 2 games
FinalDallas StarsStars4at Vegas Golden KnightsGolden Knights3WinnerVGK58%MissSpreadVGK −1.552%MissTotalOver 5.555%Hit1 of 3
FinalToronto Maple LeafsMaple Leafs3at Chicago BlackhawksBlackhawks6WinnerCHI55%HitSpreadCHI +1.550%HitTotalOver 6.555%Hit3 of 3
Mon, Nov 16 1 game
FinalMontreal CanadiensCanadiens1at New York RangersRangers3WinnerMTL55%MissSpreadNYR +1.556%HitTotalUnder 6.555%Hit2 of 3
Sat, Nov 14 1 game
FinalSeattle KrakenKraken1vs Carolina HurricanesHurricanes5WinnerCAR65%HitSpreadCAR −1.555%HitTotalUnder 6.555%Hit3 of 3
Thu, Nov 12 4 games
FinalDetroit Red WingsRed Wings4at Florida PanthersPanthers5WinnerFLA62%HitSpreadDET +1.555%HitTotalOver 5.554%Hit3 of 3
FinalColorado AvalancheAvalanche3at Ottawa SenatorsSenators4WinnerCOL55%MissSpreadCOL −1.552%MissTotalUnder 6.552%Miss0 of 3
FinalMinnesota WildWild5at Toronto Maple LeafsMaple Leafs2WinnerMIN60%HitSpreadMIN −1.555%HitTotalUnder 6.555%Miss2 of 3
FinalCarolina HurricanesHurricanes4vs Seattle KrakenKraken1WinnerCAR62%HitSpreadCAR −1.553%HitTotalOver 6.555%Miss2 of 3
Wed, Nov 11 3 games
FinalNashville PredatorsPredators4at Anaheim DucksDucks2WinnerANA56%MissSpreadNSH +1.552%HitTotalOver 6.554%Miss1 of 3
FinalUtah MammothMammoth3at Vegas Golden KnightsGolden Knights5WinnerVGK62%HitSpreadVGK −1.555%HitTotalUnder 6.554%Miss2 of 3
FinalTampa Bay LightningLightning8at Buffalo SabresSabres3WinnerTB62%HitSpreadTB −1.552%HitTotalOver 6.555%Hit3 of 3
Tue, Nov 10 7 games
FinalNashville PredatorsPredators3at Los Angeles KingsKings0WinnerNSH57%HitSpreadNSH +1.555%HitTotalUnder 6.552%Hit3 of 3
FinalDetroit Red WingsRed Wings2at St. Louis BluesBlues3WinnerSTL58%HitSpreadSTL −1.554%MissTotalUnder 5.552%Hit2 of 3
FinalFlorida PanthersPanthers4at Columbus Blue JacketsBlue Jackets1WinnerFLA55%HitSpreadCBJ +1.555%MissTotalUnder 5.555%Hit2 of 3
FinalNew Jersey DevilsDevils2at Winnipeg JetsJets4WinnerNJ62%MissSpreadWPG +1.556%HitTotalUnder 6.555%Hit2 of 3
FinalWashington CapitalsCapitals3at Ottawa SenatorsSenators2WinnerOTT55%MissSpreadOTT +1.554%HitTotalOver 6.552%Miss1 of 3
FinalMinnesota WildWild2at Montreal CanadiensCanadiens1WinnerMIN55%HitSpreadMTL +1.556%HitTotalUnder 6.554%Hit3 of 3
FinalColorado AvalancheAvalanche6at Toronto Maple LeafsMaple Leafs3WinnerCOL58%HitSpreadTOR +1.554%MissTotalOver 6.556%Hit2 of 3
Mon, Nov 9 3 games
FinalNew York IslandersIslanders2at San Jose SharksSharks3WinnerNYI57%MissSpreadSJ +1.554%HitTotalUnder 6.555%Hit2 of 3
FinalPhiladelphia FlyersFlyers3at Vancouver CanucksCanucks1WinnerPHI58%HitSpreadVAN +1.556%MissTotalOver 6.555%Miss1 of 3
FinalNew York RangersRangers1at Edmonton OilersOilers3WinnerEDM62%HitSpreadNYR +1.556%MissTotalOver 6.555%Miss1 of 3
Wed, Nov 4 2 games
FinalSan Jose SharksSharks2at Los Angeles KingsKings7WinnerSJ54%MissSpreadSJ +1.555%MissTotalUnder 6.552%Miss0 of 3
FinalChicago BlackhawksBlackhawks3at Florida PanthersPanthers5WinnerFLA65%HitSpreadFLA −1.554%HitTotalUnder 5.555%Miss2 of 3
Tue, Nov 3 1 game
FinalEdmonton OilersOilers3at New Jersey DevilsDevils4WinnerNJ56%HitSpreadEDM +1.552%HitTotalOver 6.554%Hit3 of 3
Wed, Oct 28 1 game
FinalPhiladelphia FlyersFlyers2at Washington CapitalsCapitals5WinnerWSH60%HitSpreadWSH55%No lineTotalUnder 5.555%Miss1 of 2
Tue, Oct 27 2 games
FinalBuffalo SabresSabres2at San Jose SharksSharks0WinnerSJ69%MissSpreadSJ69%No lineTotalOver 6.569%Miss0 of 2
FinalBoston BruinsBruins1at Carolina HurricanesHurricanes2WinnerCAR62%HitSpreadBOS55%No lineTotalOver 6.556%Miss1 of 2

The AI (Claude) picks every NFL game and other leagues’ bigger games (ranked matchups, national TV, games Coalition members are picking) the day before; ChatGPT and Grok pick the same games from the same facts and the same instructions. Each pick is graded on the line it saw; a pick written again after the line moved is graded on the newer line. A tie on the winner is a push, except a draw in soccer, which is a miss. Times are Eastern. Research, not betting advice. How we grade

Plan your picks with your groupPick together, split the slips, track every dollar. Free.