Books don’t just split the money
You may have heard that a book only wants equal money on both sides so it can keep the vig. A study of real bets found something smarter: books lean the line toward the side people love.
The textbook idea
If a book took the same money on both sides of every game, it would keep the vig and never care who won (Betting basics, lesson 2).
It’s a tidy picture. Real money is rarely even, though, and books have found that evening it out isn’t what pays best.
What a study of real bets found
Economist Steven Levitt looked at about 20,000 NFL bets from a 2001-02 contest at an online sportsbook. Most of them went to favorites, above all favorites on the road.
In almost half the games, at least two of every three bets were on one side. The book didn’t move its lines to even that out. It set them so the popular side covered a little less than half the time: favorites covered 48.2% from 1980 to 2001, and in his sample, bets on home underdogs won 57.7%.
| All favorites | 60.6% |
|---|---|
| Favorites on the road | 68.2% |
| Favorites at home | 56.1% |
About 20,000 bets from a high-stakes contest at one online book (Levitt, 2004).
Why leaning pays
Say $100,000 is bet on a game at −110, and 68% of it is on the favorite. Set the line at the true 50/50 and the book keeps the vig. Lean it a little toward the favorite, so it covers 47% of the time instead of 50%, and the book keeps more, because most of the money is on the side that now loses a bit more often.
| The favorite covers | The book keeps | Of all the money |
|---|---|---|
| 50% of the time | $4,545 | 4.5% |
| 48% of the time | $5,920 | 5.9% |
| 47% of the time | $6,607 | 6.6% |
Leaning the line so the favorite covers 47% of the time instead of 50% makes the book about 45% more on this game, on average. Levitt worked out about 23% more from the lean he saw.
The risk the book takes
Leaning a line means the book is taking a side. If the popular team covers, the book loses that game. Over hundreds of games it comes out ahead, which is why it can afford to.
The lean is small, about the size of the vig. Levitt’s bettors still won only 49.45% of their picks. So simply betting against the crowd isn’t enough: at −110 you still need 52.4% to break even.
Try it in the app
Quick check
1. In the study, which bets were the most popular?
68% of bets on those games went to the road favorite. Home underdogs, the side nobody wanted, won 57.7% of bets.
2. Why would a book lean a line toward the popular side instead of evening out the money?
People bet their favorite side even at a slightly worse number. Over hundreds of games, that lean adds up for the book.
Lesson 1 done. Next up: Why books shade the over.
Remember
- Books don’t always even out the money. They can lean the line toward the side people love.
- The lean is small, about the size of the vig.
- Betting against the crowd isn’t enough by itself: at −110 you still need 52.4%.
Where these numbers come from
For learning, not betting advice.