Books, exchanges, prediction markets and pick’em apps
They all let you bet on a game, but who takes the other side, and how the app makes money, is different at each.
Sportsbooks: you bet against the house
Hard Rock Bet, FanDuel, DraftKings, BetMGM and Caesars are sportsbooks. The book sets the price, takes the other side of your bet and keeps the vig.
Because it’s their money on the line, a book can cut how much a winning player is allowed to bet. That’s called getting limited.
Exchanges: you bet against other people
Novig, Sporttrade and ProphetX are exchanges. The exchange matches your bet with someone taking the other side and doesn’t care who wins.
Prices are usually better because there’s little or no vig, you can name your own price and wait for a match, and you can often sell a bet before the game ends.
Prediction markets: you buy a contract
Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood and Crypto.com sell contracts that pay $1 if something happens and nothing if it doesn’t.
The price in cents is the chance. Chiefs to win at 62¢ means the market says 62%. You can sell any time before the end at whatever it’s worth then. Most charge a small fee per trade.
| You pay | 62¢ |
|---|---|
| It pays if it happens | $1.00 |
| Profit if it happens | 38¢ |
| The chance it’s priced at | 62% |
| The same price at a sportsbook | −163 |
Pick’em apps: more or less on players
PrizePicks, Underdog, Sleeper, Dabble and DraftKings Pick6 are pick’em apps. You pick 2 to 6 players to go more or less than a stat line, and if they all hit the app pays a set multiple, like 3x for 2 picks.
You aren’t getting odds on each pick, so check what each one needs to hit. Flex plays still pay something if you miss one, but less.
| Entry | Pays | Each pick needs | Fair payout at 50% |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2 picks | 3x | 57.7% | 4x |
| 4 picks | 10x | 56.2% | 16x |
Payouts differ by app and change over time. Each pick needs to hit more than half the time just to break even.
Side by side
Which ones you can use depends on where you live. The Sportsbooks guide lists every one the app works with and what it does at each.
| You bet against | It makes money from | For example | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sportsbook | The book | The vig | Hard Rock Bet, FanDuel |
| Exchange | Other bettors | A small fee, or none | Novig, Sporttrade, ProphetX |
| Prediction market | Other traders | A fee per trade | Kalshi, Polymarket |
| Pick’em app | The payout table | Paying less than fair | PrizePicks, Underdog |
Try it in the app
Quick check
1. On a prediction market, a team to win costs 25¢. What chance does the market give it?
A contract pays $1, so a 25¢ price is a 25% chance. It pays 75¢ profit if it hits.
2. On an exchange, who takes the other side of your bet?
Exchanges only match bets. Often the other side is a market maker, which is lesson 4.
Lesson 3 done. Next up: Who’s on the other side.
Remember
- A sportsbook is the house. Exchanges and prediction markets match you with other people.
- A price in cents is a chance in percent: 62¢ is 62%.
- Pick’em apps pay a set multiple, so check what each pick needs to hit.
For learning, not betting advice.